Korean Journal of Medicinal Crop Science
[ Research Articles ]
Korean Journal of Medicinal Crop Science - Vol. 30, No. 1, pp.1-11
ISSN: 1225-9306 (Print) 2288-0186 (Online)
Print publication date 28 Feb 2022
Received 26 Oct 2021 Revised 11 Jan 2022 Accepted 11 Jan 2022
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7783/KJMCS.2022.30.1.1

Change of Proximate Composition, Antioxidant Activity, and Ginsenoside Content of White Ginseng with Different Roasting Conditions

Jin Yu1 ; In Bae Jang2 ; Ji Won Moon3 ; In Bok Jang4 ; Young Chang Kim5 ; Dong Hwi Kim6 ; Su Jeoung Suh7,
1Researcher, Department of Herbal Crop Research, NIHHS, RDA, Eumseong 27709, Korea
2Researcher, Department of Herbal Crop Research, NIHHS, RDA, Eumseong 27709, Korea
3Researcher, Department of Herbal Crop Research, NIHHS, RDA, Eumseong 27709, Korea
4Assistant director, Department of Herbal Crop Research, NIHHS, RDA, Eumseong 27709, Korea
5Researcher, Department of Herbal Crop Research, NIHHS, RDA, Eumseong 27709, Korea
6Researcher, Department of Herbal Crop Research, NIHHS, RDA, Eumseong 27709, Korea
7Researcher, Department of Herbal Crop Research, NIHHS, RDA, Eumseong 27709, Korea
로스팅 조건에 따른 백삼의 일반 성분, 항산화 활성 및 진세노사이드 함량 변화
유진1 ; 장인배2 ; 문지원3 ; 장인복4 ; 김영창5 ; 김동휘6 ; 서수정7,
1국립원예특작과학원 인삼특작부 인삼과 연구사
2국립원예특작과학원 인삼특작부 인삼과 연구사
3국립원예특작과학원 인삼특작부 인삼과 연구사
4국립원예특작과학원 인삼특작부 인삼과 주무관
5국립원예특작과학원 인삼특작부 인삼과 연구관
6국립원예특작과학원 인삼특작부 인삼과 연구관
7국립원예특작과학원 인삼특작부 인삼과 연구원

Correspondence to: (Phone) +82-43-871-5616 (E-mail) ssuh15@korea.kr

This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract

Background

The purpose of this study was to evaluate roasting conditions to optimize the physicochemical properties of ginseng to improve its utilization as a food material.

Methods and Results

Roasting was performed at different temperatures (140, 160, 180, and 200℃) and times (10, 20, and 30 min). The total phenolic content of ginseng powder was greatly between 160℃ for 20 and 200℃ for 10 min achieving a 7-fold increase (22.92 ㎎·gallic acid equivalents/g) compared to that of the control. As the roasting temperature and time were increased, the 2,2′-azino-bis(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulfonic acid) (ABTS) and 2,2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl (DPPH) free radical scavenging activities of ginseng powder were significantly increased. The total ginsenoside content was decreased with increasing treatment time at a roasting temperature of 180℃ - 200℃. The maximum total ginsenoside content (9.25 ㎎/g) was obtained at 180℃ for 10 min, however, there was no significant difference compared to that of the control. The panaxatriol Rh1 content was increased as the roasting level was increased. Overall, this study demonstrated physicochemical changes in 4-year-old ginseng roots according to the roasting conditions.

Conclusions

We suggest the optimal roasting conditions of 160℃ for 30 min or 180℃ for 10 min to minimize the reduction in total ginsenosides, yield, and proximate composition and maximize the polyphenol content and antioxidant activity.

Keywords:

Panax ginseng C. A. Meyer, Antioxidant Activity, Functional Foods, Ginsenoside, Roasting

INTRODUCTION

Ginseng (Panax ginseng C. A. Meyer) is a medicinal plant of the Araliaceae family that has been used in traditional medicine in East Asia for thousands of years (Zhuravlev et al., 2008).

Various pharmacological effects have been attributed to the saponin (ginsenoside) and non-saponin components of ginseng, including anticancer, anti-oxidant, and blood circulation, enhanced immunity, and decreased cholesterol absorption (Yun, 2001; Hong et al., 2016; So et al., 2018). While these effects have favored the use of ginseng as a material for medicine and functional foods, recent efforts have focused on its direct use as a food material.

The moisture content of ginseng roots is greater than 75%, making long-term storage difficult due to a tendency to rot. A variety of processing techniques, such as steaming, heating, and fermentation, have been explored to extend the shelf life of fresh ginseng, as well as to facilitate the absorption of its active ingredients, including ginsenosides.

Therefore, the majority of ginseng, including red and white, are consumed as processed materials (76.1%), with the remainder (23.9%) consumed as fresh ginseng, both domestically and abroad (MAFRA, 2019). However, since ginseng has generally been used as a raw material for functional foods rather than as a food material, the techniques used for its processing are limited when compared to other food materials.

The components of food vary widely depending on the method of processing. Heating can alter food components to increase their bioactivity, as well as enhance the palatability of the food itself.

Roasting is a processing method that involves heating foods for a short time with dry heat (≥ 150℃) and has primarily been used for meat, coffee, cocoa, and barley tea (Park et al., 1993). Roasting leads to both physical (e.g., starch gelatinization, protein denaturation, cell wall destruction) and chemical (e.g., browning reaction, release of internal substances) changes, which can have a positive effect on sensory quality factors, such as color and aroma. In particular, roasting temperatures above 180℃ - 200℃ affect physiological activity by changing food components via the Maillard reaction and through the decomposition of organic compounds by pyrolysis (Czerny et al., 1999; Daglia et al., 2000).

However, excessive heat can also lead to the reduction of biologically active substances, the incomplete combustion of nutrients, or the production of dangerous compounds (Nicoli et al., 1997; del Castillo et al., 2002; Jin et al., 2012). For this reason, both the roasting temperature and time play key roles in the taste and chemical components of food materials.

As for roasting studies, many have been reported on physicochemical properties, antioxidant activity and sensory characteristics of coffee and tea (Kim et al., 2019). Recently, It has been reported that antioxidant activity and antidiabetic properties of mixed tea with roasted mulberry leaves and peppermint leaves (Lee and Kim, 2020). The extraction yield of physiologically active substances such as β-glucan, catechin, and tocopherol of barley varies according to the method of roasting. It has been reported that antioxidant characteristics of roasted maize according to cultivation period and variety (Lee et al., 2018). Studies were also reported to analyze the physicochemical properties of medicinal crops such as schisandra, chicory, and cassia seed by roasting (Kim et al., 1995; Kim et al., 1998; Mok et al., 2001).

In case of ginseng, it has been reported that when ginseng is roasted, changes and dissolution of ginsenoside components occur easily. The content of water-soluble solids also increases, resulting in changes in various components and increasing physiological activity (Seong et al., 2018).

Roasting methods include direct fire, hot air and semi-hot air. Among these, the hot air method is that delivers high-temperature air directly to the inside of the drum. The advantage is that it can be roasted uniformly and in a short time, so it is a method widely used in coffee roasting.

As mentioned above, roasting can enhance the active ingredients and improve taste and aroma of ginseng. Therefore, it was attempted to apply the most popular roasting method to ginseng to use a more diverse material. In addition, this study sought to determine the optimal roasting temperature and time for 4-year-old ginseng to further the use of ginseng as a food material. This was achieved by analyzing the physicochemical changes, antioxidant activities, and active ingredients of ginseng powder and extract roasted using the general methods applied to other foods.


MATERIALS AND METHODS

1. Plant materials

Four-year-old ginseng (Panax ginseng C. A. Meyer) roots were obtained at Goesan (36.65°39´09″N/127°46´18″E), Republic of Korea. The average root weight and diameter of the fresh ginseng was 30.02 g and 19.38 ㎜, respectively.

2. Sample preparation

Ginseng roots were washed and separated into main and fine roots. The main roots were dried for 16 hat 60℃ using a hot air dryer (DY-220HR, Lassele, Ansan, Korea).

After drying, the roots were roasted at different temperatures (140, 160, 180, 200℃) and times (10, 20, 30 min) using a hot-air rotary roaster (CBR-101, Gene Café, Ansan, Korea). This roaster was capable of uniformly roasting up to 250 g of coffee beans. In this experiment, 80 - 100 g of hot-air dried and sliced ginseng root was added and performed three times.

Dried and roasted ginseng roots were pulverized using a blender (SFM-555SP, Shinil Industrial Co., Ltd., Seoul, Korea). Ginseng powder with a particle size of less than 500 ㎛ was used.

3. Sample extraction

Ginseng powder (1 g) was suspended in 80% MeOH (15 ㎖) and extracted by sonication for 1 h at room temperature (24℃) in an ultrasonic bath (WUC-D22H, DAIHAN Scientific Co., Ltd., Wonju, Korea).

The resultant extract was then collected by centrifugal separation (2,000 g, 24℃, 7 min). This process was repeated twice to obtain a final extract volume of approximately 30 ㎖.

4. Measurement of hunter’s color value and browning color

Hunter’s color value of the dried and roasted ginseng powders was measured using the L*, a*, and b* (L* : lightness, a* : red/green, b* : yellow/blue) by a colorimeter (CM-5, Konica minolta Inc., Osaka, Japan).

Browning color of the extracted samples was measured at 420 ㎚ using a UV spectrophotometer (MULTISKAN GO, Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc., Waltham, MA, USA).

5. Proximate analysis

Proximate analysis was performed in accordance with the National Institute of Agricultural Sciences and Technology (NIAST) research analysis criteria for food quality characteristics (NIAST, 2012).

Moisture content was determined by drying the samples in an oven at 105℃ to a constant weight. Crude protein content was determined using the Kjeldahl method. Crude fat content was determined with diethyl ether for 8 hours using a Soxhlet apparatus. Ash content was determined by incinerating the samples at 550℃. Carbohydrate content was calculated by subtracting the crude protein, crude fat, ash, and moisture contents from 100. The results were expressed as g/100 g fresh weight (FW).

6. Analysis of total phenolic content

The total phenolic content (TPC) was determined by modifying the Folin-Ciocalteu method (Folin and Denis, 1912). Briefly, ginseng extract (50 ㎕) was reacted with 2% Na2CO3 solution (1 ㎖) for 3 min and then treated with 50% Folin-Ciocalteu's phenol solution (50 ㎕) for 30 min at room temperature.

The absorbance of the mixture at 750 ㎚ was measured using a UV spectrophotometer (MULTISKANGO, Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc., Waltham, MA, USA). Gallic acid (GA, Sigma-Aldrich Co., St. Louis, MO, USA) was used as the reference standard, and the results were expressed as mg GA equivalents in 1 g of dried sample (㎎·GAE/g dry weight).

7. Antioxidant activity assays

ABTS (2,2′-azino-bis-(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulfonic-acid) radical scavenging activity was measured by modifying the method of Re et al. (1999). A solution of 7.4 mM ABTS (Sigma-Aldrich Co., St. Louis, MO, USA) and 2.6 mM potassium persulfate was stored in the dark for 1 day.

Following cation formation, the solution was diluted with distilled water using the ABTS extinction coefficient [ε(H2O) = 3.6 × 104 M-1·㎝-1] to obtain an absorbance value of 0.73 ± 0.02 at 735 ㎚. The ginseng extract (50 ㎕) was then added to the diluted ABTS solution (1 ㎖), reacted in the dark for 30 min, and the absorbance at 735 ㎚ was measured using a UV spectrophotometer. L-Ascorbic acid (AA, Sigma-Aldrich Co., St. Louis, MO, USA) was used as the reference standard, and the results were expressed as ㎎ AA equivalents in 1 g of dried sample (㎎·AA/g dry weight).

DPPH (1,1-diphenyl-2-picrylhydrazyl) radical scavenging activity was measured by modifying the method of Tepe et al. (2006). A 0.2 mM DPPH (Sigma-Aldrich Co., St. Louis, MO, USA) solution (0.8 ㎖) was added to the ginseng extract (200 ㎕), and the absorbance at 520 ㎚ was measured after reacting in the dark at room temperature for 30 min. AA was used as the reference standard, and the results were expressed as ㎎·AA/g dry weight.

8. Analysis of ginsenoside content

Eleven ginsenosides from the dried and roasted 4-year-old ginseng roots were analyzed.

The 11 ginsenoside standards used in this analysis were Rb1, Rb2, Rb3, Rc, Rd, Re, Rf, Rg1, Rg2, Rg3, and Rh1 (ChromaDex, Irvine, CA, USA). The mobile phase used for the analysis consisted of solvent A (water) and solvent B (acetonitrile). Powdered ginseng (0.2 g) was suspended in 70% MeOH (1 ㎖), thoroughly mixed, and extracted by sonication for 30 min at 50℃ in an ultrasonic bath. The crude extract was collected by centrifugal separation (31,000 g, 4℃, 15 min) and 1 ㎖ of the sample was passed through a Sep-Pak C18 cartridge (Waters Co., Milford, MASSACHUESTTS, USA) to remove impurities. The purified extract was then filtered through a 0.45 ㎛ membrane filter (Kim et al., 2010), and the ginsenoside content was measured using a Nexera X2 UPLC system (Shimadzu Co., Tokyo, Japan). The extract (10 μL) was analyzed using a Halo RP amide column (4.6 ㎜ × 150.0 ㎜, 2.7 ㎛, Advanced Materials Technology Inc., Wilmington, DE, USA) at a 0.5 ㎖/min flow rate, 50℃ column temperature, and 203 ㎚ UV detection.

9. Statistical analysis

Statistical analyses were performed using SAS v.9.2 (SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA). Statistical significance was determined using Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT) and One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). All data were at the 5% significance level and were reported as means ± standard deviation (SD) (p < 0.05).


RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

1. Reduction ratio, color, and browning of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions

Under the different roasting conditions, the ginseng powder reduction ratio tended to increase proportionally with the roasting level (Table 1). Reduction ration accounted for less than 5% at 140℃ treatment group, 160℃ treatment group and 180℃ for 10 min. However, it increased to approximately 7% when roasted at 180℃ for 20 min, and reached ≥ 15% after roasting at 200℃ for 20 and 30 min. The moisture remaining in the ginseng following the hot air drying likely decreased after the roasting process, with the evaporation of water accelerating as the roasting temperature and time increased.

Reduction ratio, Hunter’s color value, and browning color under different roasting conditions.

The reduction ratio ranges from 75% to 85% when 4-year-old fresh ginseng steamed and dried under the steaming conditions (90℃ - 100℃ for 12 - 24 hours) and it increased up to 90% depending on steaming temperature and time (Yu et al., 2019). And the reduction ratio of ginseng during 9 steaming process was about 79% (Hong et al., 2007). In this experiment, the average dry yield was about 25%, that is, the reduction ratio was 73%. Even if it is roasted, there is not much difference from red ginseng production. In addition, main and fine roots with high water content were used, but the reduction ratio will be reduced when all ginseng roots are used.

Although the reduction in the moisture content of the ginseng powder is advantageous in terms of storage, the reduction in yield is disadvantageous in terms of production efficiency. Therefore, the roasting level should be determined in reference to these advantages and disadvantages.

The Hunter L value, representing brightness, decreased significantly with increasing roasting time and temperature (Fig. 1). The Hunter a value, representing redness, increased to 8.28 after roasting at 180℃ for 10 min, and then decreased with longer times and higher temperatures.

Fig. 1.

Ginseng powder under different roasting conditions.Control; dried (60℃, 16 hours) ginseng powder.

For example, at 200℃, the Hunter a value rapidly decreased from 5.89 to 3.95 when roasted between 20 and 30 min. The Hunter b value, indicating yellowness, ranged from 20.29 to 21.69 after roasting at 160℃ for 20 min to 180℃ for 10 min and tended to increase significantly compared to that of the non-roasted control.

After roasting at 200℃ for at least 20 min, the color of ginseng powder is black to the naked eye, suggesting that the Hunter a and b values decrease sharply. When rice germ was roasted, the Hunter b value increased at the beginning of roasting and then decreased, with a subsequent increase in the Hunter a value (Ko et al., 2003). Therefore, Hunter b and a values tend to increase and decrease after roasting in both ginseng and rice germ.

Hunter’s color value of red ginseng powder, which was manufactured according to the red ginseng manufacturing regulations of Korea Tobacco and Ginseng Central Research Institute, was L (68.18 - 72.08), a (4.21 - 5.73), b (26.56 - 28.36) (Seo et al., 2002). This value was slightly similar to the Hunter a value of the 180 roasting treatment group and the Hunter L and 160 roasting treatment groups.

Brownness has been reported to increase significantly depending on the roasting level and decrease above certain temperatures and times (Kim et al., 2018). The increase is due to the formation of browning substances by Maillard reactions (Jing et al., 2004). The substrates of the browning reaction, sugars and amino acids, are presumed to be reduced under long-term heating at high temperatures, and become insoluble polymers via polymerization and condensation (Kwon et al., 1997).

Browning color of white ginseng powder and red ginseng on sale was 0.14, 1.28, respectively (Hong et al., 2007). Browning of white ginseng powder was similar to 140℃ for 10 min treatment. In case of commercial red ginseng, browning color was similar to the value between 180℃ for 10 min and 180℃ for 20 min.

Chromaticity and brownness are visual indicators of the degree of roasting and are important factors influencing consumer preference; therefore, these features should be considered when marketing agricultural products as food materials.

2. Proximate composition of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions

The proximate composition of ginseng powder varied with different roasting conditions (Table 2). Carbohydrate content of roasted ginseng powder ranged from 71.71 g/100g to 76.40 g/100g. When roasted at 140℃ - 160℃, it increased slightly compared to that of the non-roasted ginseng powder (control) but decreased at temperatures above 180℃.

Proximate composition of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions.

Protein content of ginseng powder increased in proportion to the roasting level, culminating in an increase of approximately 22% at 200℃/30 min (21.45 g/100g) compared to the case of the control. This differs from the work of Park et al. (1993) who found that the protein content of red ginseng decreased with an increasing roasting temperature of 170℃ - 250℃ but is consistent with results from air-roasted acorns (Jung and Park, 2019).

The moisture content of the control was 4.11 g/100g. The moisture content of the roasted ginseng powder was lower than that of the control and significantly decreased as the roasting temperature and time increased. In contrast, the fat and ash contents did not differ significantly from those of the control during roasting.

Although the composition of Korean ginseng varies greatly across different types, it is generally composed of 60% - 70% carbohydrate, 12% - 16% protein, 1% - 2% fat, and 4% - 6% ash (RDA, 2018).

The protein content of the sample in this work differs from these established measurements as only the main root of ginseng was used. In addition, the proximate composition of ginseng powder is expected to change during roasting, as heat treatment decreases the water content and destroys cell walls, resulting in the elution or destruction of organic substances (Jang et al., 2018) and the altering of carbohydrate and protein content.

3. Total phenolic content of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions

The TPC of the control was 3.53 ㎎·GAE/g and increased with roasting level, with the exception of the 200℃ treatment (Fig. 1). The TPC increased rapidly from the 160℃ for 20 min treatment, reaching the highest value of 22.92 ㎎·GAE/g with the 200℃ for 10 min treatment, which is an approximately 7-fold increase compared to the case of the control. Roasting above 140℃ for 20 min is presumed to increase TPC via the conversion of bound polyphenol compounds to free polyphenols, which are easily eluted due to the destruction of the internal tissue. This aligns with previous studies in which TPC increased in coffee and Cassia tora L. depending on the roasting level, and in grains, such as cowpea and sorghum, depending on the roasting time (Lee et al., 2013).

The TPC of 4-year-old ginseng with high heat and pressure treatment increased to 29.46 ㎎·GAE/g at 150°C for 1 hour and then decreased (Yang et al., 2006). As in this experiment, when the same part of 4-year-old ginseng root was steamed at 110°C for 48 hours, the TPC showed a peak value of 14.63 ㎎·GAE/g (Yu et al., 2019). Steaming treatment of ginseng showed a generally lower the TPC value than heat treatment.

Prolonged heating at 200℃ decreased the TPC, which is consistent with the findings of Jung et al. (2019) that TPC was significantly reduced in acorn extract air-roasted at 207℃ for 60 s as compared to that in the raw acorn. The TPC increased at a high roasting temperature and then decreased again as time passed. It has been reported that The TPC increased due to destruction of the internal tissue at a certain level of roasting conditions, but the exposed phenolic components were destroyed by excessive high temperature and lost as the roasting temperature increased (Yun et al., 2012).

The TPC is reported to have various physiological activities, including antioxidant activity, due to the ability of its phenolic ring to stabilize free radicals (Kandaswami and Middleton, 1994). As roasted ginseng powder has a higher TPC than the control, it is expected to have increased antioxidant activity. Therefore, further research regarding the roasting temperature and time of ginseng powder would aid in optimizing its TPC, and consequently, its antioxidant activity.

4. Antioxidant activity of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions

The antioxidant activity of ginseng powder was measured under different roasting conditions (Fig. 2). The ABTS and DPPH free radical scavenging activities of the control were 2.46 and 0.93 ㎎·AA/g, respectively.

Fig. 2.

Total phenolic content (TPC) of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions.The results represent the means ± SD (n = 6). Different letters within columns indicate significant differences by Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT, *p < 0.05).

Fig. 3.

(A) ABTS radical scavenging activity and (B) DPPH radical scavenging activity of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions.The results represent the mean ± SD (n = 6). Different letters within columns indicate significant differences by Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT, *p < 0.05).

The roasted ginseng powder had higher ABTS radical scavenging activity than DPPH radical scavenging activity, both of which significantly increased with increasing roasting temperature and time.

The ABTS radical scavenging activity increased ≥ 2-fold from the initial roasting treatment of 140℃ for 10 min, reaching a peak value of 13.56 ㎎·AA/g at 200℃ for 20 min. However, the activity decreased using the 200℃ for 30 min treated sample. The DPPH radical scavenging activity increased gradually from the 140℃ for 20 min and decreased after obtaining a peak value of 5.30 ㎎·AA/g at 200℃ for 20 min. This resembles a previous study investigating the antioxidant activity of red ginseng roasted from 170℃ to 250℃ (Park et al., 1993). In this study, the DPPH scavenging activity increased sharply from 170℃ to 230℃, and moderately thereafter.

Although the DPPH radical scavenging activity of roasted red ginseng was lower than that of brown rice green tea, antioxidant activity was significantly increased by more than 80% at 150°C for 30 min or more treatment (Seong et al., 2018). The fermented ginseng extract using various strains also showed similar or slightly lower values to the scavenging activity (57.66 ± 0.98%) of vitamin C (Doh et al., 2010). As such, when fresh ginseng was processed in various ways such as steaming, heat and fermentation etc, antioxidant activity tended to increase.

In general, appropriate heat treatment of raw materials used as functional food ingredients or medicines increases the antioxidant composition (Jung and Park, 2019), but results in diminished antioxidant capacity under excessive roasting conditions (Suh and Chun, 1981). The increase in antioxidant activity after roasting is linked to the production of the antioxidant melanoidin via browning reactions, such as the Maillard reaction (Lee et al., 2018). As natural phenol components exhibit radical scavenging activity (Choi et al., 2007), the increase in the radical scavenging activity of ginseng powder is likely due to a roasting-induced increase in phenolic compounds.

The results from this work indicate that roasting conditions affect the quality of ginseng powder by changing its antioxidant properties.

5. Total ginsenoside content and composition of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions

There was no consistent trend for total ginsenoside content at roasting temperatures of 140℃ - 160℃ (Table 3). In contrast, the total ginsenoside content decreased as the treatment time increased at roasting temperatures of 180℃ - 200℃. The highest total ginsenoside content was 9.25 ㎎/g at 180℃ for 10 min, but this was not significantly different from the control.

Total ginsenoside content and composition of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions.

This agrees with the findings of Yoon et al. (2005) that the high crude saponin content of ginseng roasted between 150℃ - 170℃ for 16 min - 23 min decreased at higher temperatures and times. This decrease in total ginsenoside content after reaching a maximum is due to the decomposition of polar ginsenosides, leaving only non-polar ginsenosides at high temperatures (Yang et al., 2006).

Ginsenoside is a glycoside containing a dammarane terpenoid and is classified into panaxadiol (PD) and panaxatriol (PT) lines according to the binding position of the sugar.

Ginsenoside composition changes with the roasting level. The PD ginsenoside Rg3 content increased significantly at higher roasting temperatures and times in this study. The Rg3 content increased 2-fold compared to that of the control at 180 ℃ for 20 min, attaining its highest value (0.17 ㎎/g) at 200℃ for 30 min.

In several reports, Rg3 is present in minute quantities in fresh ginseng and increases after heat treatments, such as steaming (Kim et al., 2007; Yu et al., 2019). As Rd is relatively heat stable (Sung and Yang, 1986), its content was relatively unaffected by roasting as compared to the case of the other components. The PT ginsenoside Rh1 content increased as the roasting level increased, reaching 0.24 ㎎/g at 200℃ for 20 min, which was 10 times higher than that of the control.

At a constant roasting time, Rh1 content tended to increase with increasing temperature, which is consistent with previous results that Rh1 content increased with heat treatments at temperatures above 80℃. It has been suggested that Rh1 content increases during heating due to the release of the sugar bound at the C-20 position of another ginsenoside or isomerization of the C-20 hydroxyl group (-OH) (Yang et al., 2006). Rf is reported to be relatively heat stable (Hong et al., 2007), which correlates with the finding that its content was minimally changed until 180℃ for 30 min, but rapidly decreased at higher temperatures.

The PT ginsenosides Re and Rg1 contents showed the largest decreases with increasing roasting levels. Re and Rg1 contents were decreased by 37% and 40%, respectively, as compared to those of the control at 180℃ for 30 min, resulting in 0.74 and 0.91 ㎎/g, respectively.

Polar ginsenosides, such as Re, Rb1, and Rc, have a low heat-tolerance (Hong et al., 2007), and Re and Rg1 are particularly vulnerable to heat. In the control, the PD/PT ratio was 0.56. As the roasting temperature and time increased, the ratio increased up to 1.21.

Contrary to previous work (Choi et al., 2008), this study found that PT-based ginsenosides were more unstable than PD-based ginsenosides at higher temperatures, resulting in an increased PD/PT ratio at increased roasting levels. As the heat-tolerance of the ginsenosides varies with their structure, the pattern of roasting-associated ginsenoside content also varied, and consequently affected the PD/PT ratio and total ginsenoside content.

During food processing, dangerous substances can be produced as carbohydrates, proteins, and fats undergo incomplete combustion processes. For example, benzopyrene can be produced via carbonization during the high-temperature treatment of fresh ginseng. 0.01 ppb of benzopyrene was produced when red ginseng was roasted at 150℃ for 30 min. 0.11 ppb of benzopyrene, which is about 10 times higher, was produced in roasted red ginseng under 170℃ for 30 min. However, this figure is much lower than the 2.0 ppb of black ginseng powder, which is the benzopyrene limit suggested by Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (Seong et al., 2018). Since fresh ginseng was roasted at 160℃ for 30 min and 180℃ for 10 min in this experiment, benzopyrene will be detected at a lower concentration compared to red ginseng. However, additional experiments related with benzopyrene are required under this condition in practice.

Our results confirmed that the physicochemical properties of 4-year-old ginseng roots changed according to the roasting conditions. Based on a comprehensive analysis of the results, the optimum roasting conditions to minimize the reduction in total ginsenosides, yield, and proximate composition and maximize the polyphenol content and antioxidant activity are 160℃ for 30 min or 180℃ for 10 min. Although this was set to optimal condition, further review of this process is needed to assess stability and the optimum roasting conditions may vary based on the type of ginseng used and the presence of other materials.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by a grant (PJ01333601) from the Rural Development Administration and by 2022 the RDA Fellowship Program of National Institute of Horticultural and Herbal Science, Rural Development Administration, Republic of Korea.

References

  • Casal S, Oliveira MB and Ferreira MA. (2000). HPLC/diodearray applied to the thermal degradation of trigonelline, nicotinic acid and caffeine in coffee. Food Chemistry. 68:481-485. [https://doi.org/10.1016/S0308-8146(99)00228-9]
  • Choi KH, Kwak YS, Rhee MH, Hwang MS, Kim SC, Park CK, Han GH and Song KB. (2008). Effects of pH and high temperature treatment on the changes of major ginsenosides composition in Korean red ginseng water extract. Journal of Ginseng Research. 32:127-134. [https://doi.org/10.5142/JGR.2008.32.2.127]
  • Choi PJ. (2019). Study of changes in less-polar ginsenoside contents their anticancer effects via microwave ginseng. Ph.D. Thesis. Gachon University. p.27-28.
  • Choi YM, Jeong HS and Lee JS. (2007). Antioxidant activity of methanolic extracts from some grains consumed in Korea. Food Chemistry. 103:130-138. [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodchem.2006.08.004]
  • Czerny M, Mayer F and G rosch W. (1999). Sensory study on the character impact odorants of roasted Arabica coffee. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 47:695-699. [https://doi.org/10.1021/jf980759i]
  • Daglia M, Papetti A, Gregotti C, Bertè F and Gazzani G. (2000). In vitro antioxidant and ex vivo protective activities of green and roasted coffee. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 48:1449-1454. [https://doi.org/10.1021/jf990510g]
  • del Castillo MD, Ames JM and Gordon MH. (2002). Effect of roasting on the antioxidant activity of coffee brews. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 50:3698-3703. [https://doi.org/10.1021/jf011702q]
  • Doh ES, Chang JP, Lee KH and Seong NS. (2010). Ginsenoside change and antioxidation activity of fermented ginseng. Korean Journal of Medicinal Crop Science. 18:255-265.
  • Folin O and Dennis W. (1912). On phosphotungstic-phosphomolybdic compounds as color reagents. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 12:239-243. [https://doi.org/10.1016/S0021-9258(18)88697-5]
  • Hong HD, Kim YC, Rho JH, Kim KT and Lee YC. (2007). Changes on physicochemical properties of Panax ginseng C. A. Meyer during repeated steaming process. Journal of Ginseng Research. 31:222-229. [https://doi.org/10.5142/JGR.2007.31.4.222]
  • Hong MG , Lee YH, Kim S, Suk KT, Bang CS, Yoon JH, Baik GH, Kim DJ and Kim MJ. (2016). Anti-inflammatory and antifatigue effect of Korean Red Ginseng in patients with nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. Journal of Ginseng Research. 40:203-210. [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jgr.2015.07.006]
  • Jang HL, Park SY and Nam JS. (2018). The effects of heat treatment on the nutritional composition and antioxidant properties of hempseed(Cannabis sativa L.). Journal of the Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition. 47:885-894. [https://doi.org/10.3746/jkfn.2018.47.9.885]
  • Jing H and Kitts DD. (2004). Antioxidant activity of sugar-lysine Maillard reaction products in cell free and cell culture systems. Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics. 429:154-163. [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.abb.2004.06.019]
  • Jin Y, Kim YJ, Jeon JN, Wang C, Min JW, Jung SY and Yang DC. (2012). Changes of ginsenosides and physiochemical properties in ginseng by new 9 repetitive steaming and drying process. Korean Journal of Plant Resources. 25:473-481. [https://doi.org/10.7732/kjpr.2012.25.4.473]
  • Jung SH and Park SJ. (2019). Physicochemical compositions, antioxidant activity, and sensory acceptance of oak acorn extracts with different air-roasting levels. Journal of the Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition. 48:739-747. [https://doi.org/10.3746/jkfn.2019.48.7.739]
  • Kandaswami C and Middleton E. (1994). Free radical scavenging and antioxidant activity of plant flavonoids. In Armstrong D. (ed.., Free Radicals in Diagnostic Medicine. In Wim E et al. (ed.. Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology. Springer. Boston. MA, USA. p.351-376. [https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4615-1833-4_25]
  • Kim DS, Kim HS, Hong SJ, Cho JJ and Shin EC. (2018). Changes in physicochemical and antioxidative properties of Cynanchi wilfordii Radix after a roasting treatment. Journal of the Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition. 47:363-372. [https://doi.org/10.3746/jkfn.2018.47.3.363]
  • Kim EK, Jeong YH, Gu SY, Song KY, Kim IY and Kim KY. (2019). Physicochemical characteristics of Brazilian Coffea arabica cv. Catuai coffee extracts with different roasting conditions. Journal of the Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition. 48:748-756. [https://doi.org/10.3746/jkfn.2019.48.7.748]
  • Kim EY, Jin Y, Kim KT, Lim TG, Jang M, Cho CW, Rhee YK and Hong HD. (2016). Effect of high temperature and high pressure on physicochemical properties and antioxidant activity of Korean red ginseng. Korean Journal of Food and Nutrition. 29:438-447. [https://doi.org/10.9799/ksfan.2016.29.3.438]
  • Kim GS, Hyun DY, Kim YO, Lee SE, Kwon H, Cha SW, Park CB and Kim YB. (2010). Investigation of ginsenosides in different parts of Panax ginseng cultured by hydroponics. Korean Journal Horticultural Science and Technology. 28:216-226.
  • Kim JK, Hawer WD, Ha JH, Moon KD and Chung SK. (1995). Changes of volatiles flavor components on roasting conditions in Cassia tora seeds. Korean Journal Food Science and Technology. 27:736-741.
  • Kim HJ, Lee JY, You BR, Kim HR, Choi JE, Nam KY, Moon BD and Kim MR. (2011). Antioxidant activities of ethanol extracts from black ginseng prepared by steaming-drying cycles. Journal of the Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition. 40:156-162. [https://doi.org/10.3746/jkfn.2011.40.2.156]
  • Kim HK, Lee BY, Shin DB and Kwon JH. (1998). Effects of roasting conditions on physicochemical characteristics and volatile flavor components of chicory roots. Korean Journal Food Science and Technology. 30:1279-1284.
  • Kim KY, Shin JK, Lee SW, Yoon SR, Chung HS, Jeong YJ, Choi MS, Lee CM, Moon KD and Kwon JH. (2007). Quality and functional properties of red ginseng prepared with different steaming time and drying methods. Korean Journal of Food Science and Technology. 39:494-499.
  • Ko SN, Kim CJ and Kim IH. (2003). Effects of roasting condition on the quality characteristics and oxidative stabilities of rice germ. Korean Journal of Food Science and Technology. 35:347-352.
  • Kwon JH, Ryu KC and Lee G D. (1997). Dynamic changes in browning reaction substrates of Polygonatum odoratum roots during roasting. Journal of the Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition. 26:654-661.
  • Lee JH, Kim HJ, Lee BW, Lee YY, Lee BK and Woo KS. (2018). Effect of germination and roasting treatment on the quality and physicochemical characteristics of cowpea flour. Journal of the Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition. 47:288-297. [https://doi.org/10.3746/jkfn.2018.47.3.288]
  • Lee MH, Cho JH and Kim BK. (2013). Effect of roasting conditions on the antioxidant activities of Cassia tora L. Korean Journal of Food Science and Technology. 45:657-660. [https://doi.org/10.9721/KJFST.2013.45.5.657]
  • Lee SY and Kim AJ. (2020). Development of mixed tea prepared with roasted mulberry and peppermint leaves. Journal of The East Asian Society Of Dietary Life. 30:335-344. [https://doi.org/10.17495/easdl.2020.10.30.5.335]
  • Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs(MAFRA). (2019). 2018 ginseng statistics. Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs. Sejong, Korea. p.57.
  • Mok CK, Song KT, Lee SK, Na YJ, Park JH, Kwon YA and Lee SJ. (2001). Optimization of roasting process as pretreatment for extraction of Omija(Schizandra chinensis Baillon). Korean Journal Food Sciences and Technology. 33:333-337.
  • National Institute of Agricultural Sciences and Technology (NIAST). (2012). Use of agricultural products processing. National Institute of Agricultural Sciences and Technology. Rural Development Administration. Suwon, Korea. p.1017-1019.
  • Nehring UP and Maier HG. (1992). Indirect determination of the degree of roast in coffee. European Food Research and Technology. 195:39-42. [https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01197837]
  • Nicoli MC, Anese M, Manzocco L and Lerici CR. (1997). Antioxidant properties of coffee brews in relation to the roasting degree. LWT-Food Science and Technology. 30:292-297. [https://doi.org/10.1006/fstl.1996.0181]
  • Park MH, Kim KC and Kim JS. (1993). Changes in the physicochemical properties of ginseng by roasting. Journal of Ginseng Research. 17:228-231.
  • Rural Development Administration(RDA). (2018). Ginseng(4th ed.). Rural Development Administration. Jeonju, Korea. p.275-276.
  • So SH, Lee JW, Kim YS, Hyun SH and Han CK. (2018). Red ginseng monograph. Journal of Ginseng Research. 42:549-561. [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jgr.2018.05.002]
  • Seo CH, Lee JW, Do JH and Chang KS. (2002). Quality characteristics of Korean red ginseng powder on pulverizing methods. Journal of Ginseng Research. 26:79-84. [https://doi.org/10.5142/JGR.2002.26.2.079]
  • Seong BJ, Kim SI, Jee MG, Kin SE, Kwon AR, Kim HH, Gwang YG and Lee KS. (2018). Physiochemical characteristics according to the roasting conditions and grinding grade for the development of drip type red ginseng. Journal of the Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition. 47:309-319. [https://doi.org/10.3746/jkfn.2018.47.3.309]
  • Suh CS and Chun JK. (1981). Relationships among the roasting conditions, colors and extractable solid content of roasted barley. Korean Journal of Food Science and Technology. 13:334-339.
  • Sung HS and Yang JW. (1986). Effect of the heating treatment on the stability of saponin in white ginseng. Journal of the Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition. 15:22-26.
  • Tepe B, Sokmen M, Akpulat HA and Sokmen A. (2006). Screening of the antioxidant potentials of six Salvia species from Turkey. Food Chemisty. 95:200-2004. [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodchem.2004.12.031]
  • Trugo LC and Macrae R. (1984). A study of the effect of roasting on the chlorogenic acid composition of coffee using HPLC. Food Chemisty. 15:219-227. [https://doi.org/10.1016/0308-8146(84)90006-2]
  • Yoon SR, Lee MH, Park JH, Lee IS, Kwon JH and Lee GD. (2005). Changes in physicochemical compounds with heating treatment of ginseng. Journal of the Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition. 34:1572-1578. [https://doi.org/10.3746/jkfn.2005.34.10.1572]
  • Yu J, Jang IB, Moon JW, Jang IB, Lee SW and Suh SJ. (2019). Physicochemical characteristics of a 4-year-old ginseng based on steaming temperatures and times. Korean Journal of Medicinal Crop Science. 27:86-95. [https://doi.org/10.7783/KJMCS.2019.27.2.86]
  • Yun TK. (2001). Panax ginseng—A non-organ-specific cancer preventive?. The Lancet Oncology. 2:49-55. [https://doi.org/10.1016/S1470-2045(00)00196-0]
  • Yun UJ, Yang SY, Lee HS, Hong CO and Lee KW. (2012). Optimal roasting conditions for maximizing the quality of tea leached from high functional Perilla frutescens leaves. Korean Journal of Food Science and Technology. 44:34-40. [https://doi.org/10.9721/KJFST.2012.44.1.034]
  • Zhuravlev YN, Koren OG, Reunova GD, Muzarok TI, Gorpenchenko TY, Kats IL and Khrolenko YA. (2008). Panax ginseng natural populations: Their past, current state and perspectives. Acta Pharmacologica Sinica. 29:1127-1136. [https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-7254.2008.00866.x]

Fig. 1.

Fig. 1.
Ginseng powder under different roasting conditions.Control; dried (60℃, 16 hours) ginseng powder.

Fig. 2.

Fig. 2.
Total phenolic content (TPC) of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions.The results represent the means ± SD (n = 6). Different letters within columns indicate significant differences by Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT, *p < 0.05).

Fig. 3.

Fig. 3.
(A) ABTS radical scavenging activity and (B) DPPH radical scavenging activity of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions.The results represent the mean ± SD (n = 6). Different letters within columns indicate significant differences by Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT, *p < 0.05).

Table 1.

Reduction ratio, Hunter’s color value, and browning color under different roasting conditions.

Roasting Reduction ratio2)
(%)
Hunter’s color value Browning color
(O.D. at 420 ㎚)
Temperature (℃) Time (min) L a b
1)Control; dried (60℃, 16 hours) ginseng powder. The average dry yield was about 25%. 2)Reduction ratio (%); (1 - dry and roasting yield/dry yield) × 100. Each value represents the means ± SD (n = 6). Different letters within columns indicate significant differences by Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT, *p < 0.05)
Control1) - 89.72±0.05a 0.66±0.01i 10.61±0.17h 0.033±0.006i
140 10 1.72±0.15 86.27±0.18b 3.51±0.06h 17.36±0.12d 0.182±0.012hi
20 2.55±0.20 82.37±0.49c 5.27±0.17e 19.81±0.08bc 0.408±0.040g
30 2.55±0.23 82.87±1.23c 4.83±0.47f 19.51±0.54c 0.341±0.058gh
160 10 2.64±0.10 82.27±0.07c 5.09±0.19ef 20.29±0.18b 0.410±0.106g
20 3.57±0.24 76.40±0.49d 6.89±0.26d 21.19±0.54a 0.734±0.049f
30 4.62±0.25 72.96±2.70e 7.67±0.15bc 21.31±1.31a 1.191±0.237e
180 10 4.52±0.25 71.64±1.90e 8.28±0.40a 21.69±0.37a 1.251±0.161e
20 7.48±0.36 59.67±0.90f 7.92±0.05b 14.89±0.44e 2.931±0.145c
30 7.73±0.38 58.27±0.48f 7.76±0.30b 14.14±0.56f 2.752±0.124d
200 10 8.75±0.70 55.56±1.13g 7.42±0.09c 12.47±0.78g 3.359±0.111a
20 15.34±1.10 48.54±0.29h 4.93±0.06f 5.89±0.36i 3.192±0.212b
30 17.76±1.54 46.72±0.12i 3.92±0.28g 3.95±0.27j 2.873±0.128cd

Table 2.

Proximate composition of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions.

Roasting Carbohydrate
(g/100 g)
Protein
(g/100 g)
Fat
(g/100 g)
Ash
(g/100 g)
Water content
(g/100 g)
Temperature (℃) Time (min)
1)Control; dried (60℃, 16 hours) ginseng powder. Each value represents the means ± SD (n = 6). Different letters within columns indicate significant differences by Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT, *p < 0.05).
Control1) 72.12±0.15e* 17.65±0.11h 1.11±0.08ab 5.02±0.03de 4.11±0.07a
140 10 73.40±0.07d 18.22±0.01f 0.99±0.10bc 5.29±0.02c 2.10±0.04b
20 74.96±0.10b 17.52±0.08h 1.11±0.03ab 4.85±0.02e 1.56±0..05c
30 74.35±0.30c 18.17±0.18fg 1.21±0.16a 5.16±0.03cd 1.11±0.02d
160 10 73.55±0.12d 18.42±0.06e 1.11±0.14ab 5.38±0.02c 1.54±0.06c
20 76.40±0.26a 16.78±0.20i 0.99±0.10bc 5.16±0.02cd 0.67±0.02g
30 74.95±0.14b 18.15±0.03fg 0.83±0.09c 5.35±0.04c 0.72±0.02fg
180 10 74.43±0.24c 17.98±0.16g 1.23±0.14a 5.31±0.02c 1.04±0.03d
20 73.71±0.18d 18.96±0.11d 1.28±0.08a 5.30±0.06c 0.75±0.01f
30 71.76±0.13e 20.24±0.02c 1.29±0.13a 5.65±0.03b 1.06±0.07d
200 10 71.79±0.08e 20.12±0.11c 1.17±0.07ab 5.85±0.04ab 1.07±0.01d
20 71.80±0.21e 20.61±0.07b 1.16±0.13ab 6.05±0.15a 0.37±0.04h
30 70.71±0.50f 21.45±0.04a 1.14±0.06ab 5.82±0.48ab 0.88±0.05e

Table 3.

Total ginsenoside content and composition of ginseng powder under different roasting conditions.

Roasting Panaxadiol (PD) Panaxatriol (PT) Total2)
(㎎/g)
PD/PT
Temp.
(℃)
Time
(min)
Rb1 Rb2 Rb3 Rc Rd Rg3 Re Rf Rg1 Rg2 Rh1
1)Control; dried (60 ℃, 16 hours) ginseng powder. Each value represents the mean ± SD (n = 3). 2) Total; Rb1 + Rb2 + Rb3 + Rc + Rd + Rg3 + Re + Rf + Rg1 + Rg2 + Rh1. Different letters within columns indicate significant differences by Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (DMRT, *p < 0.05).
Control1) 1.37±0.12c 0.71±0.03bcd 0.14±0.01a 0.74±0.06abc 0.06±0.003b 0.02±0.002de 1.98±0.16a 0.84±0.08c 2.27±0.09a 0.28±0.02ab 0.02±0.001g 8.43±0.51ab 0.56±0.01e
140 10 1.51±0.05bc 0.76±0.07abc 0.13±0.01ab 0.72b±0.08c 0.08±0.037b 0.03±0.004d 1.70±0.29b 0.94±0.03b 1.73±0.37b 0.28±0.11ab 0.03±0.001fg 7.90±0.22bc 0.69±0.04de
20 0.89±0.14ef 0.55±0.06cde 0.08±0.01cde 0.46±0.08e 0.05±0.003b 0.02±0.008e 0.98±0.13e 0.51±0.02e 1.20±0.17cd 0.12±0.03de 0.02±0.001g 4.87±0.31e 0.72±0.11de
30 1.06±0.27de 0.35±0.04de 0.07±0.02de 0.41±0.24ef 0.40±0.020a 0.03±0.003d 1.17±0.09d 0.66±0.11d 1.25±0.39c 0.14±0.02cde 0.03±0.003g 5.57±0.11e 0.70±0.13de
160 10 0.85±0.15fg 0.27±0.04e 0.06±0.01d 0.39±0.24ef 0.56±0.008a 0.03±0.001d 1.19±0.14d 0.64±0.12d 1.25±0.31c 0.11±0.04de 0.03±0.001g 5.37±0.34e 0.68±0.06de
20 1.47±0.04bc 0.86±0.07abc 0.11±0.02bc 0.81±0.02abc 0.43±0.036a 0.03±0.004d 1.28±0.08d 0.86±0.05c 1.68±0.19b 0.13±0.01cde 0.04±0.004f 7.69±0.44bc 0.93±0.07bcd
30 1.36±0.11c 0.95±0.00ab 0.11±0.03abc 0.78±0.03abc 0.17±0.013b 0.02±0.001de 1.19±0.04d 0.67±0.07d 1.31±0.26c 0.14±0.01cde 0.03±0.005fg 6.73±0.27d 1.03±0.13abc
180 10 1.70±0.14a 0.85±0.06abc 0.12±0.60abc 0.91±0.05ab 0.38±0.031a 0.03±0.004d 1.49±0.23c 1.12±0.06a 2.43±0.54a 0.16±0.04cd 0.07±0.002e 9.25±0.44a 0.77±0.18cde
20 1.63±0.12ab 1.09±0.21a 0.13±0.02ab 0.92±0.02a 0.05±0.0016b 0.05±0.001c 1.26±0.09d 0.81±0.03c 1.36±0.06c 0.18±0.01c 0.11±0.007c 7.60±0.16c 1.04±0.12abc
30 1.16±0.05d 0.63±0.04bcd 0.09±0.04cd 0.68±0.01cd 0.04±0.01b 0.05±0.010c 0.74±0.17f 0.47±0.08e 0.91±0.11de 0.09±0.05e 0.10±0.003d 4.96±0.24e 1.19±0.30ab
200 10 1.03±0.12def 0.91±0.02abc 0.11±0.02abc 0.69±0.02cd 0.07±0.036b 0.05±0.008c 0.78±0.04f 0.51±0.02e 0.81±0.10e 0.14±0.033cde 0.12±0.005c 5.22±0.57e 1.21±0.18ab
20 0.70±0.07g 0.65±0.05bcd 0.09±0.05cd 0.53±0.05de 0.06±0.026b 0.15±0.010b 0.43±0.13g 0.43±0.02e 0.33±0.06f 0.24±0.02b 0.24±0.006a 3.86±0.33f 1.25±0.50a
30 0.36±0.08h 0.26±0.06e 0.05±0.02e 0.28±0.16f 0.05±0.020b 0.17±0.007a 0.20±0.02h 0.26±0.03f 0.15±0.01f 0.30±0.02a 0.20±0.002b 2.27±0.32g 1.07±0.36ab